Book review Philosophy Politics Recommended Read

Book Review | Turning Back the Clock: Hot Wars & Media Populism

Book review of Umberto Eco's Turning Back the Clock.

Books are different things to different people. A good book holds the ability to instil in its readers a sense of purpose and meaning. You won’t need critics’ judgment; a good book will have you buzzing in the afterglow.

Umberto Eco’s ‘Turning Back the Clock’ (2007, Harcourt books) left me basking in the similar afterglow. Eco, by profession, is a semiotician (a student of signs and symbols), philosopher and literary critic.

‘Turning Back the Clock’ is Umberto Eco’s hand-picked collection of his essays that mostly appeared in Italian newspapers La Repubblica and L’espresso. For discerning readers and philosophy aficionados, the multifarious topics could be an enticing aspect of the book. To the less discerning audience, this diversity might just come across as a gallimaufry of author’s opinionated notions.

Predominantly, this book manifests Eco’s reflection on changes in societal landscape and the impact of mass media. In summation, ‘Turning Back the Clock’ is a peek into Umberto Eco’s brilliant mind; it sets a vantage point for others to evaluate and opine on various social and political issues.

He sets the tone in the opening chapter called ‘Some Reflections on War and Peace’. It is an astounding piece of literature on the evolution of war. Eco says that warfare has evolved from the Paleowars when the location and identity of the enemy were certain to the front-less Neowars.

The theory of ‘Maximum happiness, Minimum sacrifice’ is central to Neowars. The enemy is now mostly within, and its location is more uncertain than ever. It’s here that Eco’s ominous prediction of a permanent Neowar with lots of peripheral paleowars starts to sound realistic.

A sense of foreboding comes through from the following Eco quote: I don’t believe that on this earth men, who are wolves preying on their fellow men, will attain global peace.

Eco touches upon a host of diverse topics in the book. He draws parallels between technology and magic, muses about the carnivalization of politics and sports and much more. He also turns back the clock to the taking of Jerusalem and wallops the reader with the gory details of the crusades.

His acute antipathy toward Silvio Berlusconi and the barrage of scathing attacks against his fellow Italian constitute roughly twenty percent of the book. As a matter of fact, if you happen to be a fan of the ex-Italian PM, chances are you might have to skip a whole lot of chapters in this book.

Admittedly, the amount of Berlusconi bashing seems to reach levels of redundancy after some chapters. It reaches a level where you begin to wonder why Eco’s publisher didn’t recommend him a separate book. A separate tome for his critiques of the ex-PM. Nevertheless, that’s just a small chink in what is otherwise a solid literary armour.

Eco sneers at mass media for having degenerated into a playground for exhibitionists. I am sure he is alluding to those morons on Jeremy Kyle Show, Jersey Shore, Big Brother and so on.  He also scoffs at the way politicians these days make a beeline for prime time TV and conduct their politics on TV like gladiatorial games. And then he also takes a well-deserved pop at media for inventing news.

He quips that ‘inventing news’ doesn’t mean providing information about something that hasn’t happened; it’s making news out of something that wasn’t news in the first place.

Like an Agent Provocateur of sorts, he asks some thought-provoking and hard-to-ignore questions. In one of the chapters, he asks if a private school adjusts to the level of culturally backward students who are subsidized by the state, how will the school maintain its elite status?

Elsewhere, he sagely remarks that if you can’t justify and sympathize with Muslim fundamentalism, you must explain and understand the motives, arguments and drives that make it what it is.

“I don’t believe that on this earth men, who are wolves preying on their fellow men, will attain global peace.” – Umberto Eco

Two characteristics strongly underpin the writings of Umberto Eco. First, his unpretentious historical erudition, and second, his straightforwardness in calling a spade a spade.

Even with all the topical multiplicity, ‘Turning back the Clock’ turns out to be a riveting book. I highly recommend it to the students of philosophy and sociology. On a personal note, at no point, while reading the book did I bother to look at the number of pages remaining. To risk an irrelevant analogy, it was like watching an out-and-out action movie; the action just won’t stop!

©2017 BookJelly. All rights reserved

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: